Schedule and Pricing - Magic Lantern Show

2019 Shows for Individual Theatergoers

This Is My Country – Patriotic American History Show

Shows at 7:00PM

Every Saturday in July and August

PLUS July 2 – 4.

Underground Rail Road Show

Shows at 7:00PM

Every Friday July 5 – August 30

Theater of Fear – Halloween Show (Age 13 and up only for this show.)

Nightly at 8:00pm, October 22 – 26 and October 29 – November 2

A Christmas Journey – Christmas Magic Lantern Show

Shows at 2:00PM and 7:00PM

November 29 & 30

December 7, 14, 21, 23, 24, 26, 27, & 28.

At the Door: Adults: $19.95; Children (4-12): $13.95

Underground Railroad Show and Theater of Fear Show same price online as at door.

Patriotic Show and Christmas Show Online: Adults: $14.95; Children (4-12): $11.95 (You SAVE $5 per adult)

Guarantee your seat by booking online. We’ll even pay the service charge!
Buy Tickets!               Purchase Gift Card!



The Plain & Fancy Theater is operated by the Amish Experience, located on the property of Plain & Fancy Farm, Route 340, between Bird-in-Hand and Intercourse. Get Directions

Be sure to discover all the other activities, tours, buggy rides, food, and lodging available at the Amish Experience at Plain & Fancy Farm by exploring our website. We look forward to seeing you!

Shows for Groups (20+)

For a very special treat for groups visiting Amish Country, include a Magic Lantern Show (show duration approximately 45 minutes) at the Plain & Fancy Theater. Daytime and evening shows on the hour can be easily arranged through our group department for groups of 20 or more.

  • Bible Stories Show 
  • This Is My Country! – A Patriotic Show
  • Victorian Christmas
  • Underground Railroad Experience

Download a color PDF of all the Magic Lantern information.

Contact us for discounted group pricing at 800-555-2303, ext. 214, 217, or 218, or by email.