Schedule and Pricing - Magic Lantern Show

2019 Shows for Individual Theatergoers

This Is My Country – Patriotic American History Show

Shows at 7:00PM

Every Saturday in July and August

PLUS July 2 – 4.

Underground Rail Road Show

Shows at 7:00PM

Every Friday July 5 – August 30

Theater of Fear – Halloween Show (Age 13 and up only for this show.)

Nightly at 8:00pm, October 22 – 26 and October 29 – November 2

A Christmas Journey – Christmas Magic Lantern Show

Shows at 2:00PM and 7:00PM

November 29 & 30

December 7, 14, 21, 23, 24, 26, 27, & 28.

At the Door: Adults: $19.95; Children (4-12): $13.95

Underground Railroad Show and Theater of Fear Show same price online as at door.

Patriotic Show and Christmas Show Online: Adults: $14.95; Children (4-12): $11.95 (You SAVE $5 per adult)

Guarantee your seat by booking online. We’ll even pay the service charge!
Buy Tickets!               Purchase Gift Card!


Other Showings

You are welcome to also join one of the private 50-minute group shows. Tickets are not sold online, but may be purchased 15 minutes before showtime on the day of the show in the box office. Below are upcoming group shows. However, please call the box office a week in advance to confirm show date and time, and let us know how many in your party plan to attend. 717-768-8400, ext.210.

Current group shows scheduled through May, 2019: Underground Railroad: April 5 (9am), 6 (11am), 11 (9am); May 2 (2pm), 3 (9am & 2pm), 6 (1pm), and 16 (9am). Bible Stories: April 25 (2pm). Remember to call us about a week in advance to confirm the group is still coming.


The Plain & Fancy Theater is operated by the Amish Experience, located on the property of Plain & Fancy Farm, Route 340, between Bird-in-Hand and Intercourse. Get Directions

Be sure to discover all the other activities, tours, buggy rides, food, and lodging available at the Amish Experience at Plain & Fancy Farm by exploring our website. We look forward to seeing you!

Shows for Groups (20+)

For a very special treat for groups visiting Amish Country, include a Magic Lantern Show (show duration approximately 45 minutes) at the Plain & Fancy Theater. Daytime and evening shows on the hour can be easily arranged through our group department for groups of 20 or more.

  • Bible Stories Show 
  • This Is My Country! – A Patriotic Show
  • Victorian Christmas
  • Underground Railroad Experience

Download a color PDF of all the Magic Lantern information.

Contact us for discounted group pricing at 800-555-2303, ext. 214, 217, or 218, or by email.