The Story of Jacob’s Choice

“Compelling” best describes the emotional story of “Jacob’s Choice,” told through the everyday lives of the fictional Fisher family, an Old Order Amish family of today. Shown on five different screens, witness young Jacob’s struggle in choosing the Amish church, or leaving behind family and community for the allure of the modern world.

Experience the horrendous religious persecution of their forefathers and take part in the perilous voyage to America, all magically heightened by wind, rain, smoke, fire, ghostly and other immersive special effects that thrill the senses.

Jacob’s challenges with faith, tradition, and loved ones in a fast-changing world is a story that touches each of us, young and old, in a poignant and memorable way. More than any other Amish attraction, “Jacob’s Choice” will leave you with an understanding of what it means to be Amish, and the ties that continue to bind the community together through the centuries.

2020 Show Times & Pricing 

Show duration is approximately 35 minutes. 

$10.95 ages 13+

$7.95 ages 4-12

Add House & School tour to take advantage of discounted Combo Ticket pricing.  Combo Ticket available online at a further discount.  No coupon code needed.

Purchase tickets for “Jacob’s Choice” in-person at the Amish Experience Box Office. For your best value, purchase the SuperSaver at least one hour in advance online. That’s a savings of over $16 compared to individual pricing, and we pay your service fee!  Tickets are refundable up to one hour prior to start of activity.

2020 Hours:

Runs every hour on the hour Monday-Saturday 10:00am-5:00pm and Sundays 12:00pm-5:00pm now through October 31, 2020.

Runs every hour on the hour daily in November 2020, 12:00pm-5:00pm. (Closed Thanksgiving Day.)

Runs every hour on the hour 12:00pm-5:00pm December 5, 12, 19, and 22-27, 2020. (Closed Christmas Day.)

Closed 12/28/2020 through mid-March 2021 for our winter off-season.



HomeRotator_TheaterThe dramatic tale of “Jacob’s Choice”, an Amish family’s effort to preserve a lifestyle and a culture, is unforgettably told through a high-tech, multi-media production with visual effects, sound design, and mechanical effects. Visitors experience “400 years of history in 40 minutes of magic.”

The Amish Experience Theater has been designed to break down the barrier between audience and movie screen. Changes in the environmental space within the theater literally allow you to “experience” the action as it unfolds around you.

Neither an IMAX nor a 3-D movie, the theater set consists of actual barn siding, with five multiple projection screens, 100,000 watts of theatrical lighting, custom-designed mechanical special effects, four-dimensional sound imagery, an original musical score, and unforgettable ghosting effects.

“Jacob’s Choice,” nevertheless, remains at its heart an emotional, personal story of an Amish family and the resilience of Amish culture through the ages.